Our Christmas worship setlist at Light Church Olongapo is built almost entirely from old hymns. Every December we come back to Silent Night, Joy to the World, Hark! The Herald Angels Sing, and O Come, O Come, Emmanuel, and every December the congregation sings them like they have been waiting all year to. Here are the Christmas hymns we use, the keys and tempos we play them in, and how we pair them so the set flows.
Here in the Philippines, Christmas starts early. The carols are playing in the malls by September, so by December everyone in the room knows the melodies. That is a gift for a worship team, but it also makes it easy to play them on autopilot.
Why We Lean on Hymns at Christmas
We use hymns at Christmas because everyone in the room already knows them, from the kids to the grandparents. When we start Joy to the World, nobody needs to look at the screen.
These hymns are also in the public domain, so we can print lyric sheets, project the words, and share chord charts with the whole team without worrying about licensing. We wrote more about this in why we still sing hymns at our modern worship church.
The Christmas Hymns We Play Every December
Each one links to our chord chart.
O Come, O Come, Emmanuel in Em, slow, around 68 BPM
Come, Thou Long-Expected Jesus in G, around 76 BPM
Silent Night in G, 3/4 time, around 60 BPM
What Child Is This in Em, 3/4 time, around 72 BPM
O Little Town of Bethlehem in G, around 72 BPM
Hark! The Herald Angels Sing in G, around 92 BPM
Joy to the World in D, around 96 BPM
Go Tell It on the Mountain in G, around 92 BPM
We never play all eight on one Sunday. Four is our limit, or the set starts to feel like a Christmas concert instead of worship.
How We Pair Christmas Hymns So the Set Flows
The easiest transitions are between relative keys. G major and E minor use the same notes, so moving between them barely needs a transition.
Our favorite pairing is Silent Night into What Child Is This. Both are in 3/4, Silent Night sits in G and What Child Is This sits in Em, so the band can hold the same waltz feel while the keys player drifts into the minor chord. If relative keys are new to you, our Relative Key Finder shows the pair for any key.
On the Advent Sundays, we pair O Come, O Come, Emmanuel with Come, Thou Long-Expected Jesus the same way, Em into G. The first song carries the waiting, and the second one answers it.
The other transition we use every year is Joy to the World into Hark! The Herald Angels Sing. Joy to the World ends on a D chord, and D is the five chord in the key of G. So when the last line lands on D, the band is already sitting on the chord that leads home into G. We just hold it, count in, and go.
Watching the Tempo on Familiar Songs
The biggest problem we have with Christmas hymns is tempo, not chords. Everyone knows these songs, so the band relaxes, and a relaxed band drifts. Silent Night slowly speeds up, and Joy to the World somehow ends slower than it started.
What helped us was setting a tempo for every song and checking it with the Metronome at the start of rehearsal. Silent Night at 60 BPM feels almost too slow at first, but by the second verse that slowness is what makes it feel like a lullaby.
Keeping Familiar Hymns From Feeling Like Autopilot
When a song is this familiar, one small change per song goes a long way.
Start Silent Night with just one guitar or the piano and the vocals, then bring the band in on the second verse.
Drop everything except the vocals for the last verse of O Come, O Come, Emmanuel, then bring the band back for the final refrain.
Give Go Tell It on the Mountain to the youth. It is upbeat, easy to sing, and a good closing song.
Read the Bible passage behind the song before you play it. Joy to the World is Isaac Watts' paraphrase of Psalm 98, and reading it first changes how the room hears the opening line.
A Sample Christmas Sunday Setlist
Here is a four-song set for the Sunday closest to Christmas:
Joy to the World (D, 96 BPM)
Hark! The Herald Angels Sing (G, 92 BPM)
Silent Night (G, 60 BPM)
What Child Is This (Em, 72 BPM)
It opens with the two bright songs, then slows down so the set ends quietly, ready for prayer or the preaching. If your vocalist needs a different key, use the Transpose Calculator and move the pairs together. If Silent Night goes up to A, move What Child Is This to F#m. You can also save the set as a free setlist and share it with your team.
These hymns have been sung for hundreds of years, and they will be sung long after us. Our job is not to make them new. It is to help the people in the room sing them with their whole heart, one more December.